Is the Harris Index Right for Your Loop Assessment Needs?

The Harris Index is an Often Cited Measure of Control Loop Performance.  Even So, Its Complexity Could Mean that Other KPIs Are a Better Alternative.

Predicting the weather is difficult – just ask a meteorologist. Even with the help of advanced analytics few seem to get it right with consistency – just ask any parent who has dealt with an unplanned snow day. In addition to more advanced tools meteorologists rely on basic measures such as Temperature, Wind Speed, and Atmospheric Pressure. Their continued reliance on these simpler metrics provides food for thought. Descriptive statistics used in assessing control loop behavior fall into one of three categories: 1) Central tendency, 2) Shape and 3) Spread. Whereas measures of central tendency provide insight into a process’ center or average state of operation and measures of shape describe the distribution of data values, measures of spread indicate the degree to which individual values are clustered or to which they deviate from the mean value in a distribution. Each can provide unique value in terms of understanding a given control loop’s performance.

The Harris Index is a frequently mentioned measure of spread. Calculation is based on a process’ current control relative to a known minimum variance control (MVC) value. In calculating the MVC value an auto-regressive moving average model must be fit to the process data. This is a predictive model that represents the action a minimum variance controller would take. As a result the reliability of the Harris Index depends on the efficacy of that model and its estimation of a process’ Dead-Time.

While the Harris Index is thoroughly documented, consider the following:

  • Simple Statistics

Once the Harris Index is configured values can be computed automatically with the help of software. The index’s output is relative to a minimum variance value of one (1) and it can vary significantly from day to day. As such, the value can be difficult to interpret – so wrote Horch and Heiber.

  • Model Maintenance

Processes are subject to time-variant behavior and their dynamics steadily change. As a result, the predictive model on which the Harris Index is based will decrease in its efficacy over time. The values will cease to provide an accurate measurement of the associated process’ spread.

  • Assessment Alternatives

There are numerous and alternative descriptive statistics for measuring spread. Among them are Average Absolute Error and Standard Variation. While not normalized, both metrics track how well a controller is able to maintain Set Point. Since they are not model-based each can provide an accurate assessment of performance in spite of evolutionary changes in process dynamics.

As with predicting the weather, it’s often worthwhile to start with basic metrics. While the Harris Index is a proven descriptive statistic and offers unique insight into process performance, it is more complex than other available metrics. Indeed, there are numerous others that are simpler to both calculate and interpret. Given the breadth of control loops at a typical production facility, simpler may be better.

These resources offer related content:

How Do I Calculate Dead-Time?

  Calculate Dead-Time By Visually Inspecting Your Step Test Data Adults can learn a thing or two from children. That's especially true when it comes to matters of time. Whereas adults view it as fashionable to show up to a social event 15 or more...

Why Does Control Loop Performance Change Over Time? What is Time Variant Behavior?

Changes To Regulatory Control Loop Performance Are Occurring Everyday...Right Under Your Nose! You visit a doctor annually for a physical examination.  Your car gets an oil change every 3,000 miles.  Your company assesses profit versus loss every 3 months.  The list of routine "check ups"...
shutterstock_425988259

How Often Should PID Control Loops be Tuned?

  The Age of Just In Time Tuning Has Arrived and It Answers The Question: When Should I Tune My PID Control Loops? When it comes to PID control loops and the right time for tuning practitioners generally fall into one of two camps. There...

Still looking for more?

Now that you’ve gotten the basics, connect with our team to learn how our people, processes and technologies can help you optimize.