The Oscillation Metric Can Identify a PID Controller that Requires Tuning, But More Often Than Not it Provides an Indication of Loop Interaction or Mechanical Issues.
Various key performance indicators (KPIs) help manufacturers to pinpoint under-performing PID control loops. Those KPIs identify characteristics in the data that correlate with poor tuning among other negative performance issues. Oscillatory behavior is one such characteristic that is common in industrial applications and regularly attributed to poor tuning.
The Oscillation Metric is a standard KPI used in control loop performance monitoring (CLPM) solutions and suitable as a secondary metric for identifying tuning issues. Indeed, the Oscillation Metric is a less obvious indicator of poor tuning and it generally requires corroboration from other KPIs. Consider the following:
Rule Out Instability
More often than not oscillatory behavior is indicative of instability. Behavior that results in a high Oscillatory Metric value is often the result of mechanical issues. A final control element (FCE) that’s oversized or that has stiction can drive persistent and variable process behavior.
Corroboration of poor controller tuning can be found in other metrics such as Output Reversals, Output Travel, and Stiction. These other metrics focus on the FCE’s performance. If values are low for these KPIs, then a high Oscillation Metric value does suggest that tuning of the controller is an appropriate corrective action.
Investigate Interaction
Behavior originating with upstream processes can filter downstream and cause other loops to oscillate in response. Most production facilities operate a tangled web of control loops that interact with each other.
Long-lasting oscillations that taper off are symptomatic of poor tuning and will trigger a high Oscillation Metric value. Such variability can be the result of a load change, an adjustment to Set Point, or other process disturbance. If not a mechanical issue, then the oscillations are most likely due to a controller that’s tuned too aggressively and that stretches out the loop’s Settling Time.
A high Oscillation Metric value can be corroborated with a similarly high value for Absolute Average Error (AAE). AAE measures a given loop’s ability to track Set Point. A loop can be deemed as being in need of tuning if these two metric values are high. Viewing the process data is an even more basic method of confirming that the controller requires tuning. If the Process Variable can be seen to taper off over time, then tuning is the correct course of action.
It’s common for practitioners to associate oscillatory loop behavior with poor controller tuning. While there is a link between a high Oscillation Metric value and poor tuning, more often than not this form of variability is tied to loop interaction and mechanical issues. The next several posts will focus on KPIs that identify the need for tuning more clearly.
What is Non-Steady State Modeling or NSS Modeling?
Why LOOP-PRO is the Industry-Leading PID Tuning Software Non-Steady State (NSS) Modeling is the ability to calculate an accurate process model when the associated data is oscillatory, is noisy, or has extensive Dead-Time. It's a highly valuable capability when tuning difficult PID loops, and it...
How Do I Isolate the Root-Cause of Control Loop Performance Issues?
Power Spectrum: A Forensic Tool for Advanced Loop Interaction and Root-Cause Analysis Finding controller performance issues in a typical production facility is not hard, but isolating and correcting their root-cause can present real challenges. Ask around stories abound of production staff who tune a...
How Does Loop Monitoring Help with Root-Cause Analysis?
For most individuals, a house is the most expensive asset that they’ll ever purchase. And while living there a homeowner can expect a significant problem or two to arise whether that problem involves a leaky roof, termite damage, or some other costly issue. A downside...
Still looking for more?
Now that you’ve gotten the basics, connect with our team to learn how our people, processes and technologies can help you optimize.